15 Best Restaurants in Islamorada to Try in 2025

Islamorada, Florida, is a destination known for its stunning waterfront views and delicious cuisine. Whether you're a local or just passing through, here are 15 restaurants in Islamorada that you must try in 2025. Each offers something unique, making this list essential for food enthusiasts.

Square Grouper Islamorada delivers fresh seafood in a casual yet polished atmosphere. Known for its innovative dishes and excellent service, this spot is perfect for a relaxed meal with family or friends. Don’t miss their signature lobster rangoons. Their menu also features an array of daily specials that highlight the best local catches.

Lazy Days is a long-time favorite among locals and visitors alike. Situated right on the water, it’s known for its "hook and cook" option, where you can bring in your catch of the day, and their chefs will prepare it for you. It’s an ideal spot for enjoying a true taste of the Florida Keys. The laid-back ambiance makes it a great choice for casual dining or celebrating special occasions.

A popular choice for both locals and tourists, Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar offers live music, unbeatable sunset views, and a menu filled with seafood favorites. Be sure to try their conch chowder and key lime pie. Their tiki-style setting provides a quintessential Keys experience that keeps patrons coming back.

Located near Robbie’s Marina, the Hungry Tarpon Restaurant combines a laid-back vibe with classic Keys flavors. The restaurant serves crowd-pleasing dishes like fish tacos, shrimp, and grits for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The waterfront views and friendly staff add to the restaurant’s charm, making it a must-visit spot.

Wahoo’s is the go-to spot for seafood lovers. With its expansive menu, there’s something for everyone, from the fresh catch of the day to hearty seafood pasta. The scenic view of the marina adds to the experience. Their happy hour specials and signature cocktails make it a great choice for evening outings.

Marker 88 is known for its beachfront dining and timeless appeal. Established in 1967, this restaurant offers an array of seafood dishes paired with breathtaking sunset views. Their signature smoked fish dip is a must-try. Families and couples alike enjoy the relaxed atmosphere and attentive service.

Morada Bay provides an upscale dining experience with its French-Caribbean-inspired menu. The restaurant’s beachside location makes it a top choice for a romantic dinner or special occasion. Favorites include the yellowtail snapper and coconut curry. The beautifully lit outdoor seating area enhances the overall dining ambiance.

Chef Michael’s is a fine dining establishment that specializes in creatively prepared seafood. The intimate setting and exceptional service make it a standout. Highlights include the hogfish with a citrus butter sauce and decadent desserts. Their wine list is carefully curated to complement the menu offerings.

Islamorada Fish Company combines a relaxed atmosphere with a focus on fresh, high-quality seafood. Adjacent to the Bass Pro Shops, it’s a convenient stop for a delicious meal. Favorites include stone crab claws and fried grouper sandwiches. Guests also appreciate the large outdoor seating area overlooking the water.

Island Grill offers a blend of traditional seafood dishes and innovative flavors. Located near the ocean, it’s an excellent choice for casual dining. Their tuna nachos and mahi Reuben are crowd favorites. Regulars love the live music and friendly service that create a welcoming environment.

For a lively atmosphere, head to Hog Heaven Sports Bar and Grill. This waterfront spot combines comfort food with a variety of drink options. Popular dishes include the BBQ ribs and the shrimp po’ boy. Sports fans appreciate the multiple TVs, and the outdoor seating offers stunning views.

Off the Hook Churrascaria stands out for its Brazilian-inspired menu, featuring a variety of grilled meats and seafood options. This restaurant is ideal for those looking to try something a little different in Islamorada. Their all-you-can-eat experience is perfect for hearty appetites and adventurous diners.

Ziggie & Mad Dog’s offers a classic steakhouse experience in the heart of the Keys. Known for its prime steaks and fresh seafood, it’s an excellent choice for a special night out. Be sure to make reservations in advance. The elegant yet welcoming décor enhances the overall dining experience.

Pierre’s Restaurant is an elegant dining destination that offers a sophisticated menu inspired by French and global cuisines. With its beautiful colonial-style building and beachfront setting, it’s a top choice for a memorable dining experience. Guests often rave about the attentive service and exquisite presentation of each dish.

Twisted Shrimp is a casual spot known for its creative twists on shrimp dishes. From shrimp tacos to shrimp po’boys, the menu is packed with flavorful options that showcase the versatility of this seafood staple. Their generous portions and budget-friendly prices make it a hit with families and groups.

Pine River Realty, led by Dominic Rivera and Alexander Pinero, has built a reputation for delivering exceptional service to clients in Islamorada and beyond. With extensive experience as Islamorada real estate agents, they are well-equipped to help buyers and sellers achieve their goals. Their team understands the challenges of navigating the real estate market and works diligently to ensure a smooth and stress-free process for every client.

If you're looking to buy or sell a home or have any questions about the Islamorada, FL, real estate market, or in top Islamorada communities like Port Antigua, Safety Harbor, White Marlin, Plantation Key, Duck Key, Venetian Shores, and more, contact Pine River Realty today.